Gwyneth Wentink, Canto Ostinato Review

Simeon ten Holt’s Canto Ostinato is a monumental piece in the minimal music genre renowned for its hypnotic repetition and meditative qualities. Originally composed for multiple keyboards, it has seen various interpretations and arrangements over the years. Gwyneth Wentink’s adaptation for solo harp, released in May 2024, introduces a new dimension to this celebrated work, merging ten Holt’s intricate composition with the harp’s ethereal sound.

Composed in 1976, Canto Ostinato is a prime example of ten Holt’s minimalist style. It employs simple structures, shifting rhythms, and repetition to create a hypnotic and meditative effect that has captivated audiences worldwide.

The piece is built from 106 short sections, each of which performers can repeat any number of times. This flexibility allows for performances of varying lengths, ranging from a single hour to many hours. Additionally, the instrumentation is not fixed; while Canto Ostinato is most commonly played on two or four pianos, it can be adapted for different instruments and combinations, offering a rich tapestry of sound possibilities.

As ten Holt’s most famous work, Canto Ostinato enjoys immense popularity. Its unique soundscapes and the ability to transport listeners on a profound musical journey have made it a staple in the repertoire of minimalist music, continually drawing new fans and inspiring varied performances.

Wentink’s approach to adapting Canto Ostinato for the harp reflects a reverence for the original and innovative interpretation. She meticulously transcribed the piece, tackling the inherent challenges of chromaticism on the harp, which she discussed in depth in her reflections on the transcription process. The harp’s seven-pedal mechanism, requiring rapid changes to achieve the chromatic variations, posed a significant challenge. However, Wentink successfully navigated these obstacles, maintaining the piece’s structural integrity while translating the piano’s expansive sound palette into the harp’s distinct tonal qualities.

Ten Holt’s approach to harmony in Canto Ostinato reflects his concept of “tonality after the death of tonality.” He viewed the tonal center not as a fixed point but as something fluid and evolving, capable of losing its traditional authority and merging into chromaticism, thus treating all tones with equal importance. This allowed him to create a piece where harmony is dynamic and open to interpretation, with the traditional tonal center losing its authority and merging into chromaticism, treating all tones with equal importance. This philosophy embodies the themes of death and transformation through distance and resolution that are woven into the fabric of Canto Ostinato.

Wentink’s arrangement captures the essence of the original, preserving the recognizable pulse and organic flow that make Canto Ostinato compelling. Her virtuosity goes beyond overcoming technical challenges; she leverages the recording studio to layer multiple harp tracks, creating a sense of dialogue and interaction within the piece. As she describes: “Although this is a solo recording… you will sometimes hear one harp, sometimes two, sometimes even three harps layered on top of each other.” This innovative technique adds depth and complexity to the sound, fostering the impression of a small ensemble performing together rather than a single instrument. By layering multiple harp tracks, Wentink not only showcases the harp’s unique capabilities but also adds a new layer of depth and texture to the piece.

Wentink’s performance reflects her technical skill and deep musicality, bringing out the lyrical qualities of the motif. Her touch on the harp is engaging, as she plays with dynamics, articulation, and phrasing to shape the passages with precision and fluidity. Her interpretation reveals the emotional depth of Canto Ostinato, capturing its meditative quality while infusing it with her personal touch. Wentink’s ability to convey the piece’s intricate nuances and dynamic shifts highlights her exceptional skill and intimate understanding of ten Holt’s composition, as well as the unique voice of the harp.

Listening to Wentink’s solo harp rendition of Canto Ostinato is a hypnotic experience. The harp’s gentle resonance and rich harmonics provide a fresh perspective on the piece, enhancing its meditative and contemplative qualities. This arrangement honors the spirit of ten Holt’s work and expands its expressive potential. The recording’s sound quality is impeccable, capturing the harp’s nuances in vivid detail, and the liner notes offer insightful context into Wentink’s artistic journey with the piece.

Gwyneth Wentink’s arrangement and performance of Canto Ostinato for solo harp is a remarkable achievement. She has successfully bridged the gap between ten Holt’s visionary composition and the harp’s unique sonic landscape, offering listeners a new way to experience this minimalist masterpiece. This recording is  recommended for  longtime fans of Canto Ostinato, classical music fans and music lovers who like the harp’s capability to mesmerize. That’s the short of it!

Connect with Gwyneth Wentink: Website |